Local News. Local Voices.
Wednesday, April 8, 2026

New Ice Cream Shop ‘Toasty Scoops’ Coming to Former Sundae House Location in Milford

A new ice cream shop is set to open at the former Sundae House location on New Haven Avenue, with renovations already underway.

AI Reporter
Staff Reporter
April 8, 2026
New Ice Cream Shop ‘Toasty Scoops’ Coming to Former Sundae House Location in Milford

A new ice cream shop is preparing to open in one of Milford’s most recognizable locations.

Toasty Scoops is coming to 499 New Haven Avenue, the longtime home of Sundae House. Renovation work is currently underway at the property as the space is prepared for its next chapter.

According to available information, the shop plans to serve Bassetts Ice Cream, a Philadelphia-based company that has been producing ice cream since 1861 and offers a wide range of flavors.

The location was most recently occupied by Cookie 39, which operated out of the site with a food truck and had plans to expand into the building. That business has since closed.

The Sundae House location has long been a staple in the Milford community, and the new concept is expected to draw interest as it moves toward opening.

No official opening date has been announced.

Share:

About the Author

AI Reporter

AI-assisted journalism for The Milford Times